Is Gareth Southgate right to axe Wayne Rooney from England team?

Is Gareth Southgate right to drop Wayne Rooney from England's starting line-up against Slovenia? Read what the Soccer Saturday pundits have to say and then cast your vote in our poll...

England will attempt to make it three wins from three in their World Cup qualifying campaign when they face Slovenia on Tuesday, but Sky sources understand Rooney will be benched for the trip.

The captain and all-time leading scorer was booed by some sections of the crowd during Saturday's 2-0 Wembley win over Malta and interim boss Southgate, who will face the media alongside Rooney on Monday evening - live on Sky Sports News HQ from 6.30pm - is set to partner Eric Dier with Jordan Henderson in midfield.

England captain Wayne Rooney is expected to be named on the bench by Gareth Southgate for Tuesday
England captain Wayne Rooney is expected to be named on the bench by Gareth Southgate for Tuesday's World Cup qualifier with Slovenia

Phil Thompson and Charlie Nicholas give their verdict on Southgate's expected big decision but do YOU think it's the right one? Read on and then give us your view...

Thommo: Timing is harsh

I think the time has been coming since he lost a regular place for Manchester United as you're usually picked for what you do for your club, but the timing seems a bit odd.

Wayne Rooney has started Man United games from the bench
Wayne Rooney has started Man United games from the bench

He played okay against Malta but he had so much time on the ball. He was playing more square passes, not displacing anybody, whereas Henderson played more forward, chance-creating balls, which you wouldn't expect.

It wasn't Rooney's fault we didn't win by more though - and that their goalkeeper had an incredible game. We were unfortunate not to have won by a cricket score.

Was that Rooney's fault? Probably not, so it does seem a bit harsh.

Wayne Rooney lined up in midfield against Malta but England struggled to break down the minnows
Wayne Rooney lined up in midfield against Malta but England struggled to break down the minnows

Charlie: Brave from Southgate

I think they could take Rooney out of the side and it would be better balanced, but I don't think Rooney is doing anything wrong. He won more challenges and completed more passes than most against Malta and he's doing what he has to do with the pace he's lost.

Rooney failed to inspire England to success at Euro 2016
Rooney failed to inspire England to success at Euro 2016

I've been a Rooney fan of all my life and I'm not going to be critical of him now. I've been that lad who came into the first team at 16, 17 and you get to that stage where you lose a yard of pace and now maybe he's slowing the team down.

Having listened to Southgate quite a lot, I do not feel for one second that he is bowing to public pressure. He's looked at the Malta game and thinks Rooney is slowing the team down.

Former Scotland international Paul Lambert tells Sky Sports News that Wayne Rooney would be
Former Scotland international Paul Lambert tells Sky Sports News that Wayne Rooney would be 'put on a pedestal' for his achievements in other countries

He needs his team to play quicker and has pinpointed Rooney is preventing that so has made his decision, which you've got to admire him for. It's the same with Manchester United; they want Paul Pogba's energy and drive.

Watch NOW TV

Watch Sky Sports for just £6.99. No contract.

If it goes wrong for England, who is going to get the stick? It won't be Wayne Rooney anymore. It's a courageous decision to identify him as the problem and make the change.

Watch Gareth Southgate and Wayne Rooney face the media from 6.30pm on Sky Sports News HQ.

You can watch England's tour of Bangladesh, plus Premier League __football and the British Masters on Sky Sports. Upgrade now and enjoy three months at half price!

Also See:

  • Axed Rooney to face media
  • Rooney 'shocked' by booing
Search